- Sep 27, 2017
- 1,942
- 6,442
I feel you may have missed my point to some degree. Although I'm not a fan of incest, I see no reason why a good writer couldn't create a realistic story arc to cover this kink. Back when I started playing & the story was more balanced between the various fetishes, keen incest followers were seeking the development of a loving relationship between mother & son, built up over time, encompassed within the now infamous slow burn. As the Parkers are a middle class, wealthy, educated family this would have chimed better with 'realism' than what we have now with the totally ludicrous "race" between Dylan & Sam, where Dylan is just another example of teen porn shota-lite, with his added advantage of everyday access to Sophia. I understand L&P is trying to please his schoolboy fans who, presumably, identify with Dylan & Sam but the story is now cliched & has glaring inconsistencies. Forget realism, ('cos the Dev has), there's barely any basic logic left in the tale of "sex education." Putting it more crudely, it's not enough if there's to be any 'realism' at all, that Dylan is handsome, athletic, has a big knob & became a martial artist after 2 lessons. Sophia's 'frustration' with her sex life has also been badly written. Even if it wasn't, her first ports of call wouldn't include her own son. Putting the two of them together in incestuous situations may suit fans who just want to get on with the fucking, (sometime in the next 30 years, when they'll be middle aged) but their motivation has not been convincing.Some decisions are simply not possible no matter how some might wish them to be. A porn game, especially one with incest content, will never be realistic. It's just like you can't eat boiling ice cream.
That L&P claims otherwise is, in my opinion, wrong or at least misunderstood. In a porn game, a developer can put wight on creating a coherent story and characters that don't behave like sex dolls. It's more realistic than some of the other games here, but it's not a realistic game. Also, L&P seems to me to put a lot of emphasis on realistic graphics. But a porn game will never be realistic, because realism and porn are kind of mutually exclusive.
Anyway, Anyone who thought that a (real world) realistic porn game could be possible should reconsider their own expectations. One must not believe everything that L&P says. At the end of the day, he is only human and makes mistakes. Even more, I don't think anyone here should have the goal that AWAM is (real world) realistic.
We all make mistakes but IMO the Dev no longer has the commitment to the quality writing for which evidence exists from previous years, that shows what he can accomplish when he is on form. He probably wouldn't acknowledge that mistakes had ever been made. I believe that there will be no return to form, because he's chosen to write a generic teen porn game, rather than an erotic adult VN. It's far easier that way but I do believe he should re-write his promotional blurb/mission statement. "His game, his choice," so let him ruin what could have been the best 3D porn game of the 21st century. 'What's it to me?' is easily answered. This story, with the top quality renders, was the best game in town & it's disappointing to watch, (out of curiosity...& why I'm still here with no game to play anymore), its decline into mediocrity. Expectations for something better followed naturally from the Dev's statements, the artwork itself & the previous genuine commitment to quality, that used to be observable in the round & not just for renders.
I totally disagree that porn & realism are mutually exclusive, even in a work of fiction. I recommend the memoirs of the 18th century lover of many women Casanova, or the Victorian era biography, "Walter, My Secret Life." These are both factual but I believe they could well have been exaggerated &/or embellished. As for actual fiction I recommend the work of Anais Nin, as a good starter, showing how to maintain a veneer of realism. As for filmed fiction, I remember a 70's Swedish porno entitled "The Sex Tile," where a tile falls from a roof, hitting a woman & turning her into a nymphomaniac. It was so dire that half the audience, (including me), spent the 2nd half of that movie in the bar. It was unrealistic & boring but it did have lots of sex & didn't take 30 years. I also recall "Naked Tango," an 80's film, where a woman is abducted for sex & at one point shoots one of her molesters. That doesn't sound erotic but the story was engrossing & strangely believable, with well-written characters & plot twists. One film had a good story, the other one didn't. That's why I've said before that L&P should read or watch some classic or even half-way 'decent' porn, if he's out of ideas. It's not hard & it's not like he doesn't have the time. It's nothing like trying to eat boiled ice-cream either.
Last edited: